Introduction
The communication network plays an important role in the cities’ resilience against natural disasters such as earthquakes and fire accidents. If this network has appropriate resilience and does not fail, it can play an important role in reducing casualties from accidents. Access routes as a communication network of the city are very important for rescue forces to reach the accident scene in the shortest possible time and continue operational measures. Various accidents and events have occurred in the Tehran metropolis, Iran. The present study aims to investigate the current and ideal state of physical and infrastructural resilience of District 20 of Tehran based on the geographic information system (GIS) in order to help the Tehran Fire Department during crises and natural disasters.
Materials and Methods
First, three criteria, seven sub-criteria, and 21 indicators were collected to evaluate the physical and infrastructural resilience of the fire stations. Considering that some criteria and sub-criteria are preferable to other criteria and play a significant role in the infrastructural and physical resilience, 15 researcher-made questionnaires were completed by experts from fire departments in Tehran. They were asked to rate the importance of the criteria from 1 to 9. The weight of these criteria was calculated using the Expert Choice 11 software. The inconsistency ratio for judgment consistency was less than 0.1. By layering the criteria using the weights obtained from the analytical hierarchical process (AHP) method in the ArcGIS software, version 10.6 and overlaying the layers, the final resilience map of District 20 was prepared.
Results
The first examined criterion was the infrastructure resilience, which had three sub-criteria, including: Fire stations (number and area of fire stations, number of vehicles and equipment, population density, number of personnel, number of hydrants), vital arteries (roads, power transmission, and gas lines), and relief and military centers (health centers, military centers). The second criterion was physical resilience, which had two sub-criteria of occupations (low-risk places, high-risk places, moderate-risk places) and urban fabric (worn fabric, historical buildings, bridges). The third criterion was environmental resilience with the sub-criteria of geographical features (slope, faults, and canals) and environmental sustainability (green space of public and private roads).
Based on the AHP results and the output of Expert Choice 11 software, the infrastructure resilience was the first priority (weight=0.731), followed by the physical resilience (weight=0.188) and environmental resilience (weight=0.081). Based on the zoning map of resilience in the context of health, safety, and environment, it was found that 3.3% of the area (729,718 m2) had low resilience, 35.38% (7,802,578 m2) moderate resilience, 29.54% (6,513,646 m2) high resilience, 30.1% (6,639,824 m2) very high resilience, and 1.65% (364,196 m2) extremely high resilience. The results of analyzing the functional radius of seven fire stations showed that fire stations (fire, rescue, and support) in old neighborhoods with narrow passages (region 1 and the southern part of region 4) face accessibility challenges which should be considered in order to make the area resilient to fires and accidents.
Conclusion
According to the results, the District 20 of Tehran has appropriate physical and infrastructural resilience to fire and accidents.
Ethical Considerations
Compliance with ethical guidelines
This research was conducted in compliance with the ethical principles. Since there was no experiment on human or animal samples, the need for an ethical code was waived.
Funding
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Authors' contributions
All authors contributed equally to the conception and design of the study, data collection and analysis, interpretation of the results, and drafting of the manuscript. Each author approved the final version of the manuscript for submission.
Conflicts of interest
The authors declared no conflict of interest.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like thank the Technology and Information Unit of the Tehran Fire Department for providing information and all firefighters and experts who participated in responding to the questionnaire.
References
Aghayani, P., & Nikbakhsh, E. (2024). [A review of resilience and fairness concepts and modeling in humanitarian logistics using a meta-analysis approach (Persian)]. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge , 14 (1), 2-23. [DOI:10.32598/DMKP.14.1.801.1]
Anjerani, N., Bigdeli Rad, V., & Pakzad, S. (2023). [A comparative study on the realization of urban resilience in three old, moderate, and new fabrics of Qazvin City, Iran based on perceptions of residents (Persian)]. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge,13 (3), 374-391. [DOI:10.32598/DMKP.13.3.594.3]
Arasteh, M., Baghban, A., & Baghban, S. (2020). [Identification of Key Factors Affecting Urban Resilience with a Foresight Approach (Case Study: Mashhad Metropolis) (Persian)]. Physical Social Planning, 7(2), 63-78. [DOI:10.30473/psp.2020.7007]
Aysham, M., Molaei A., & Ezzati Mehr, M. (2023). [Analysis of the spatial distribution of fire stations in Tabriz city with a passive defense approach (Persian)]. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge, 13 (1), 19-34. [Link]
Ebrahimipour, M., Ziari, K., & Ardalan, D. (2021). [Explaining the pattern of physical resilience measurement in river-centered city against the impact of floods (case study: Tonekabon City) (Persian)]. Geographical Planning of Space, 11(41), 43-68. [DOI:10.30488/gps.2020.214382.3159]
Eric, H. (2023). Resilience engineering in operations and resilience training for firefighters [ A. Khairdast& Afrasiab. E. Khodabandehloo, Persian trans.]. Tehran: Danesh Binoyad Publications. [Link]
Eshghi Chaharborj, A. (2018). [City resilience to earthquakes with a futures research approach, case study: District 1 of Tehran Municipality(Persian) [PhD dissertation]. Ardabili: University of Mohaghegh Ardabili.
Ghasemi, R. , Omidvar, B. and Behzadfar, M. (2020). [Study of the Effectiveness of "Technical-Physical" and "Socio-Economic" Strategies in Improving Urban Resilience against Earthquakes (Persian)]. Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR), 8(1), 99-114. [DOI:10.22059/jurbangeo.2019.278571.1080]
Ghochani, S. K., Attari Rahimi, H., & Akbaregli, F. (2016). [Locating suitable emergency accommodation spaces in cities during times of crisis (Case study: District 11 of Mashhad Municipality)(Persian)] [MA thesis]. Mashhad: Payam Noor University.
Hajarian, A. (2024). [Locating the optimal areas for multipurpose urban shelters based on the principles of passive defense in Isfahan, Iran (Persian)]. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge, 14 (1), 44-59. [DOI:10.32598/DMKP.14.1.803.1]
Hamidi, A. (2023). [Presenting strategies for reducing the physical vulnerability of Kermanshah city due to earthquakes (Persian)] [PhD dissertation]. Tabriz: University of Tabriz.
Kamran, M. (2022). Role of cultural heritage in promoting the resilience of linear/critical infrastructure system with the enhancement of economic dimension of resilience: A critical review. International Journal of Construction Management, 22(7), 1345-1354. [Link]
Kazeminia, A. (2018). [Locating the construction of emergency shelters in Kerman city using GIS (Persian)]. Bi-Quarterly Scientific and Research Journal of Crisis Management, 16, 47-59.
Kheirdastat, A. Jozi, S. A., Rezaian, S., & Mirza Ebrahim Tehrani, M. (2024). [Locating emergency accommodation in District 19 of Tehran using multi-criteria decision-making method (Persian)]. Journal of Human and Environment, 1(22), 54-35. [Link]
Kheirdast, A., Demirchi, E. S., Padash, A., Khodabandehlou, E. A., & Mohammadi Jahdi, Z. (2024). [Relationship of work safety climate with organizational cynicism and career Resilience of firefighters (Persian)]. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge (quarterly), 14(2), 178-191. [DOI:10.32598/DMKP.14.2.826.1
Khodabandehlou, E. A., Hemmasi, A. H., Lahijanian, A., Hassani, A. H., & Mohammadi, A. (2024). [Identification and prioritization of criteria affecting the resilience of Tehran Fire Department using the analytic network process method (Persian)]. Quarterly Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 26(4). [Link]
Kim, Y. (2021). Building organizational resilience through strategic internal communication and organization–employee relationships. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 49(5), 589-608. [Link]
Liu, B., Chen, X., Zhou, Z., Tang, M., & Li, S. (2019), Research on disaster resilience of earthquake-stricken areas in Longmenshan fault zone based on GIS. In D. J. Parker, E. C. Penning-Rowsell (Eds.), Environmental Hazards and Resilience: Theory and Evidence (pp.50-69). London: Routledge. [Link]
Masoomi, M. T., & Rajabzadeh, M. (2021). [Investigating the vulnerability of Ardabil city road network against natural disasters (earthquake) (Case study: Imam Khomeini Street, Shahr) (Persian)]. Journal of Geography and Environmental Hazards, 10(3), 141-161. [DOI:10.22067/geoeh.2021.67019.0]
Moghimi, S., & Monsefi, D. (2019). [Locating suitable space for temporary accommodation of earthquake victims using hierarchical analysis and weighted linear combination based on GIS, case study: Shahroud city (Persian)]. Journal of Spatial Analysis Environmental Hazarts, 6(1). [Link]
Nasiri Hendeh Khaleh, E., Rostami, S. & Shirini, M. (2023). [Location analysis of Karaj central disaster management (Persian)]. Human Geography Research, 55(3), 83-96. [Link]
Pelling, M., Comelli, T., Cordova, M., Kalaycioğlu, S., Menoscal, J., & Upadhyaya, R., et al. (2024). Normative future visioning for city resilience and development. Climate and Development, 16(4), 335-348. [Link]
Rahimi Juneghani, A., & Nooraie, H. (2024), Evaluation of the physical-functional resilience of Isfahan City center using spatial statistics methods and ELECTRE*. Geo-Spatial Information Science, 1-18. [Link]
Rezaie shahabi, R. , Arab, A., Ahmadi, H., Pishva, A., & Shahbakhsh Mosazehi, M. E. (2023). [Evaluating the Vulnerability of the Urban Fabric of District 18 of Tehran under the Influence of Land Subsidence using ANP and GIS (Persian)]. Journal of Geography and Environmental Hazards, 11(4), 193-219. [DOI: 10.22067/geoeh.2022.76899.1235]
Roosta, M. , Karimkoshteh, N., & Azarm, Z. (2024). [Rereading local community resilience indicators in dealing with crisis an analysis of the narratives and experiences of saadi neighborhood residents in Shiraz During the 2019 Flood Disaster (Persian)]. Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR), 12(1), 85-101. [Link]
Sadeghi Pour, T. , Hajipour, K., & Sadeghi, A. (2023). [The Role of Urban Planning in Post Disaster Recovery through Site Selection of Crisis Management Support Shelters (Case Study: Third District of Shiraz Municipality) (Persian)]. Emergency Management, 12(1), 120-138. [Link]
Saeedi, R. , Aghamohammadi, H. , Alesheikh, A. A., & Vafaeinejad, A. (2024). [Smart emergency services using geographical information system and Internet of Things (Persian)]. Iranian Journal of Remote Sensing and GIS, 16(2), 159-178. [DOI:10.48308/gisj.2024.229150.1128]
Sarreshtehdari, A., & Elhami Khorasani, N. (2022). Post-earthquake emergency response time to locations of fire ignition. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 26(7), 3389-3416. [Link]
Sauti, N . S & Daud, M. E & Kaamin, M., & Sahat, S. (2021). GIS spatial modelling for seismic risk assessment based on exposure, resilience, and capacity indicators to seismic hazard: A case study of Pahang, Malaysia. Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, 12(1), 1948-1972. [Link]
Sayahpoor, A. , Hematiyan, F., & Shoul, A. (2019). Organizational Resilience Process Analysis Using Interpretative Structural Modeling (Case study: Sapco). Journal of Iranian Public Administration Studies, 2(1), 123-147. [DOI:10.22034/jipas.2019.90667]
Sun, W., Bocchini, P., & Davison, B. D. (2020). Resilience metrics and measurement methods for transportation infrastructure: The state of the art. Sustainable and Resilient Infrastructure, 5(3), 168-199. [Link]
Ghadiri , M., & Tehranchi , A. ( 2019). [ Fire prevention and protection strategies in cultural-historical buildings and textures (Persian)]. Qazvin: Qazvin Academic Jihad Publications. [Link]
Yazdani, M., & Farzaneh Sadat Zaranji, Z. (2024). [Optimum Location of Physical Expansion of Sardasht City Using Combined Methods and Transfer Process Fuzzy Network of Spatial Information System (Persian)]. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge, 13 (4), 474-489. [DOI:10.32598/DMKP.13.4.779.1]
Zardan, M. (2017). [Investigating the effect of transformational leadership on organizational resilience with the mediation of emotional intelligence in fire stations in Rasht City (Persian)] [MA thesis]. Industrial Management (Production), North Strategy Higher Education Institute.
Zebardast, E. and Gheshlaghpour, S. (2024). [Evaluating the resilience of transportation infrastructures in Tehran Metropolis. Case Study: Localities of Two (Region 9), Four (Region 6) and Five (Region 1) Districts (Persian)]. Emergency Management, 12(2), 191-205.[Link]
Zhaleh, M., & Charehjoo, F. (2021). [Measurement and zoning of physical resilience of urban neighborhoods against earthquake (Persian)]. Emergency Management, 10(1), 83-99. [Link]